By: Autumn Augustus
Introduction:
In a dimly lit room, the young boy confides with a haunting whisper, "I see dead people," a famous line from the 1999 movie "The Sixth Sense" that continues to influence paranormal media today. The film attracted a lot of attention, spurring discussions about clairvoyance and other paranormal beliefs. Numerous other paranormal films and television series have been produced as a result of this film. This raises the question of how the media has portrayed paranormal beliefs and how that has impacted both our individual beliefs and our society as a whole.
In today's media-saturated society, the portrayal of supernatural phenomena in pop culture has a profound impact on public perceptions and beliefs. From television shows to movies to online content, media representations of the paranormal shape our understanding of the mysterious and the unexplained. In this article, we will be discussing the relationship between media influence and belief formation by focusing on the cultivation theory. Through this exploration, we seek to contribute a deeper understanding of the complex relationship between media, cognition, and belief formation in contemporary society.
Cultivation Theory Overview:
According to the communications and sociological framework known as "cultivation theory," prolonged media consumption alters how people view the world and behave in daily life. George Gerbner developed cultivation theory in 1969 as a reaction to the media effect research tradition, which at the time focused only on the immediate effects of media exposure. Gebner argued that since the media has the power to shape people's attitudes, values, and beliefs, repeated exposure to media messages will eventually translate into reality. Gebner also created the phrase "The Mean World Syndrome," which characterizes a cognitive bias in which people perceive the world as more dangerous than it actually is after witnessing violent acts. For example, individuals who watch a high volume of crime dramas on television may develop an exaggerated fear of crime in their own communities, despite statistical evidence suggesting otherwise. This phenomenon highlights how media portrayals can distort individuals' perceptions of reality, leading them to overestimate the prevalence of negative events.
Other well-known terms that Gebner has also coined are resonance and mainstreaming. Mainstreaming refers to the process by which television viewers from diverse backgrounds are exposed to the same labels and images on a regular basis, leading them to develop a shared worldview. For instance, advertising often promotes certain beauty standards, such as thinness for women and muscularity for men, as ideal and aspirational. Through repeated exposure to these portrayals viewers may internalize and accept these standards as societal norms, contributing to body dissatisfaction and the perpetuation of unrealistic beauty ideals. On the other hand, resonance occurs when television stories resonate with viewers' real-life experiences. For example, individuals who have personally experienced mental health struggles may find resonance in media portrayals of mental illness and recovery. Seeing accurate and empathetic representations of mental health issues in television dramas or documentaries can help viewers feel understood and less stigmatized, encouraging open conversations and de-stigmatization of mental health concerns in society. These concepts of mainstreaming and resonance are commonly observed in pop culture and everyday life, highlighting the pervasive influence of media on individuals' perceptions, attitudes, and behaviors.
Application to Paranormal Beliefs:
The predictions of the cultivation theory about how media exposure affects belief in the paranormal are consistently supported by research findings. Research has indicated that people who watch more TV series, films, and documentaries with paranormal themes also tend to believe in more supernatural things. In contrast to individuals who watched such programs less frequently, viewers of paranormal media were more likely to report believing in ghosts and other supernatural entities, according to a 2019 study by Irwin and Wilson. Comparably, a survey by Bader and Mencken (2020) found that people who regularly read paranormal books or interact with paranormal content online have higher levels of belief in paranormal activity. These results are consistent with the cultivation theory, thereby influencing people's conceptions of what is true and plausible. Consequently, the media's portrayal of the paranormal plays a significant role in shaping societal beliefs, demonstrating the powerful impact of repeated exposure to such themes.
Types of Media Content:
Beliefs in the paranormal are fostered and reinforced by a variety of media content types. Television programs with a paranormal theme, like "Ghost Hunters" and "The X-Files," captivate audiences with dramatized investigations into psychic phenomena, ghost sightings, and extraterrestrial encounters, portraying these events as credible or even authentic. Horror films such as "The Conjuring" and documentaries about haunted houses or UFO encounters similarly blur the boundaries between fact and fiction by engrossing viewers with fabricated proof that support popular beliefs about paranormal activity. Periodically, news reports on paranormal events present different points of view and add to the public conversation about the veracity of these phenomena. In addition, peer interaction and the sharing of paranormal content on various social media platforms offer a forum for exchanging theories, personal accounts, and purported evidence, which in turn builds a community and sways beliefs. Collectively, these interactions influence and normalize paranormal beliefs, which helps explain why they are so widely accepted in modern society.
Audience perceptions and beliefs about the paranormal are influenced to differing degrees by different media content genres and formats. Fictional genres like horror films and supernatural thrillers frequently use exaggerated portrayals of ghosts, demons, and other paranormal beings in an effort to arouse suspense and terror. With their thrilling stories and jump scares, these narratives captivate audiences, but they also have the potential to propagate cultural ideas about the presence and potential perils of supernatural forces. Documentary formats, on the other hand, offer what are supposedly factual investigations into paranormal events, presenting a stronger case for the existence of the supernatural through expert opinions, alleged evidence, and interviews. When used with scientific or investigative rigor, this method can give paranormal claims a sense of legitimacy. Though it occurs less frequently, news coverage adds another level by placing paranormal events within journalistic standards. Depending on the editorial position and style of coverage, this can potentially legitimize these phenomena in the eyes of the public. Further influencing people's perceptions are interactive spaces like social media and online forums, where people can encounter skepticism as well as support from like-minded others. In general, audiences' portrayals, perceptions, and internalization of paranormal beliefs are greatly influenced by the genre and format of media content. Thus underscoring the intricate relationship between information, amusement, and belief formation in media consumption.
Psychological Mechanisms at Play:
A number of psychological processes, which influence how media consumption shapes beliefs and perceptions in regards to paranormal phenomena, are the driving forces behind the cultivation effects in media psychology. Selective exposure is important because people are more likely to seek out media content that confirms their preexisting beliefs in the paranormal, which over time serves to strengthen those beliefs. Social comparison encourages people to contrast their own experiences and beliefs with those portrayed in the media, which may normalize paranormal beliefs by making them seem common or credible. Concurrently, media portrays and perpetuates paranormal ideas more frequently, increasing cognitive accessibility. This increases people's mental access to and plausibility of these beliefs when interpreting unclear or unexplained events. Collectively, these mechanisms within the framework of cultivation theory demonstrate how media content plays a role in the social construction and normalization of paranormal beliefs.
These psychological processes have a significant impact on people's attitudes and beliefs when they interact with media portrayals of the paranormal. By encouraging people to contrast their own experiences and beliefs with those portrayed in media narratives, social comparison then intensifies this effect and may cause people to align their beliefs with perceived societal norms presented in the media. At the same time, cognitive accessibility makes sure that people's minds are able to quickly and credibly process paranormal explanations and interpretations, particularly when confronted with unclear or unexplained events. The way in which media representations not only reflect but also actively shape the cultural acceptance and prevalence of paranormal beliefs is demonstrated by this combination of mechanisms found in cultivation theory. This helps to legitimize paranormal beliefs and integrate them into larger societal discourse.
Future Directions and Recommendations:
Prospective research paths may concentrate on experimental investigations that explore the causal mechanisms behind the effects of cultivation on beliefs related to the paranormal. These investigations could focus on the ways in which individual differences, exposure duration, and particular media content interact to influence beliefs about paranormal events. Interventions intended to lessen the impact of media cultivation on the formation of beliefs may benefit from an understanding of these mechanisms. It's also critical to suggest methods for teaching media literacy and developing critical thinking abilities. Developing critical thinking abilities, skepticism, and media bias awareness can enable people to assess paranormal depictions in the media critically. These educational strategies may assist people, particularly vulnerable populations, in better navigating media influences and developing more informed perspectives on paranormal phenomena by encouraging a more discerning approach to media consumption.
Future studies should examine the underlying causal mechanisms that underlie the effects of media cultivation on paranormal beliefs, with a particular emphasis on individual variations, the length of exposure, and media content in particular. The processing of information is changing quickly due to the emergence of technologies like virtual reality and artificial intelligence. This could lead to more immersive environments and tailored content, which could amplify beliefs in the paranormal. This emphasizes how important it is to teach critical thinking and media literacy so that people can resist the pull of the media. Comprehending and tackling the consequences of these technologies is essential, highlighting the necessity of continuous investigation and preemptive actions to lessen their influence on the formation of beliefs.
Conclusion:
Important discoveries about the impact of cultivation theory on media-portrayed paranormal beliefs highlight the critical role that extended media exposure plays in forming and sustaining beliefs in paranormal phenomena. According to cultivation theory, people who are repeatedly exposed to paranormal content may develop a worldview that is consistent with media narratives, which may cause them to exaggerate their beliefs in ghosts, aliens, or psychic abilities. It is essential to comprehend the psychological processes that underlie cultivation effects because they shed light on the ways in which belief formation is influenced by selective exposure, social comparison, and cognitive accessibility. The aforementioned observations carry significant consequences for societal perspectives, cultural standards, and personal conduct. They underscore the importance of interdisciplinary cooperation between psychologists, media scholars, and educators. Evidence-based interventions are necessary to enable people to critically navigate media influences and form more nuanced perspectives on paranormal beliefs. Examples of these interventions include critical thinking training and media literacy programs. In order to support informed decision-making and the well-being of society, it is necessary to conduct continuing research and take proactive steps in addressing the intricate relationship between media, cognition, and belief formation.
References:
American Psychological Association. (n.d.). Apa PsycNet. American Psychological Association. https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2008-12896-001
Geusens, F. (2023). “I see dead people”: Exploring the associations between watching horror and belief in the paranormal. Psychology of Popular Media. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1037/ppm0000513
Maltby, John & Day, Liza. (2001). Spiritual involvement and belief: The relationship between spirituality and Eysenck's personality dimensions. Personality and Individual Differences. 30. 187-192. 10.1016/S0191-8869(00)00024-6
Milton, J. and Wiseman, R. (1999), A meta-analysis of mass-media tests of extrasensory perception. British Journal of Psychology, 90: 235-240. https://doi.org/10.1348/000712699161378
Perera, A. (2023, September 7). Gerbner’s cultivation theory in media communication. Simply Psychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/cultivation-theory.html#What-is-Cultivation-Theory
Sparks , G., & Miller, W. (n.d.). Purdue News. Media messages may encourage paranormal belief.
Sparks, G. G., Nelson, C. L., & Campbell, R. G. (1997). The relationship between exposure to televised messages about paranormal phenomena and paranormal beliefs. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 41(3), 345–359. https://doi.org/10.1080/08838159709364412
Stise, R., Bingaman, J., Siddika, A., Dawson, W., Paintsil, A., & Brewer, P. R. (2023). Cultivating paranormal beliefs: how television viewing, social media use, and podcast listening predict belief in UFOs. Atlantic Journal of Communication, 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1080/15456870.2023.2187803
van Elk, M., & Aleman, A. (2017). Brain mechanisms in religion and spirituality: An integrative predictive processing framework. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 73, 359–378. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2016.12.031
Vinney, C. (2019, October 23). What is cultivation theory?. ThoughtCo. https://www.thoughtco.com/cultivation-theory-definition-4588455
Comments